You might be an Eclectic Outsider if:
● You are comfortable in a wide variety of settings or groups, but don’t feel completely at home in any of them.
● You have different friends for different interests, because nobody seems to share all of your interests.
● Many of the movies you see are in languages you don’t speak.
● You like new things, just because they are new, different just because they are different. (Mae West: “Between two evils, I always choose the one I haven’t tried before.”) So your life may have more breadth. Like my friend Juan, who told me, “I met my wife at a reggae dance and my best friend at a Samoan picnic.” A non-EO wouldn’t have met those people.
EOs are interested in their own culture, but not more so than other cultures. They probably don’t have a circle that they spend most of their time with, but move among many circles. Because of this pattern, they might appear to others as loners.
How Does One Become an EO?
I became aware of being an outsider around age 20. I joined many formal and informal groups – political, cultural, and social – but none of them felt like home. I would contribute as best I could, but never got in too deep. I used to consider that a failing, a sign that I couldn’t commit, but now it seems the best way to participate for someone like me.
EOs seem to run in families – if one or both of your parents were eclectic, you are likely to be, too. I know mine were.
Children of immigrants and people with non-traditional sexuality tend to be EOs. Robin, a beloved manager at the apartment complex where I live, came to San Francisco from Missouri “because I was gay. They just didn’t seem to have room for me.” But when he got here, he invited a straight male acquaintance to be his roommate. He participates in and organizes community events for everyone. And he’s planning to move back to Missouri when he can, to create a senior housing community there, using some of the skills he has learned in California.
Certainly there are many gay men in SF who are neither eclectic nor outsiders, just as immigrants may not become EOs if their cultural community is large enough to meet all their needs. When there aren’t many of your people around, you are pushed to reach out to other types of people.
Downside of Being Eclectic
The problem with being an EO is that you don’t fit in easily. So at times you feel less supported, less secure. You don’t have a community backing you up whether you’re right or wrong. If you’re hanging out with a group of people who don’t speak your language or know anything about your culture, you won’t feel completely understood. If you’re alienated from your birth family / culture / community, you have lost the main support that most people have.
EOs often experience hostility from people in their own birth culture because they don’t follow its norms, while groups they are “visiting” may like them but not trust them completely. They may experience discrimination or problems at work, because many companies value conformity over productivity.
The upside is that life is more interesting, more varied. You experience different things, know different things. It can be more fun. Many outsiders see their status as a burden, though. They feel lonely. Many find a good alternative to physical belonging on-line. Social networks work well for them.
Others seek to create their own communities, often called “tribes” or “chosen families.” I prefer to look at it differently. An EO is not a loner, an outcast, or a misfit. There’s no need to cut yourself off from your family or community. Just be proud of your identity and your role, and realize the problems and the positives that come with it.
In an article called “How to Love Being a Misfit,” Maggie Lyon of the web site Positively Positive advised “Find a sense of belonging inside of you…Celebrate being different.” The author of Find Your Truth, another web site wrote, “There’s value in being a misfit…it offers a person the freedom to live a genuine life.”
I believe most insiders are living genuine lives, too. But EOs are valuable. We’re needed. So let’s enjoy it. If you feel you don’t have a group, this is your group. We should celebrate each other, even if we don’t have much in common except our difference.
Works for me – where do I sign up?
Since the second world war there has been a great movement of people across the globe, now estimated at 200 million living outside the country or nation of birth, so the unthinkable dilemmas arise, as told by BBC yesterday, How to Observe Ramadan fasting in the Arctic circle?
I have been fortunate to travel around the world on a regular basis, in fact I am always somewhere else, and I am grateful for the wonderful people I have met on the road, all of them so different from one another. I am a citizen of one country, maintain a home in another, but spend time in two other countries on a regular basis. Compartmentalization of ones lives, is what came to my mind when I read David’s blog. It is true my friends in Indonesia would be out of place in Havana, who would not fit in well with my friends in France, who would find it uneasy with the literary crowd of India.
One other disadvantage of being an EO, I might add, is that, many people would think that you are lying when you try to explain what is that you do …
Best wishes and Shalom
This article has helped me unload a pile of self-judgement that has accumulated over the years (that I never felt as a teenager, for some reason, even though I was a misfit then). Thanks a lot. I feel a lot freer now and will share the article with others!
I’ll link to this thoughtful post in the next Bayview Footprints Local News, David. It resonnates with me, absolutely!
Fascinating, David. I guess I am a semi-EO, as I have needed to fit in for various personal and professional reasons – but have always been comfortable with those outside my boxes. Whether generational, gender, racial/ethnic etc. I’m thinking we are the Gladwellian Connectors.
Oh, I liked this one. Never heard of the term “EO”, but seems like you nailed it, David.
Yes, I feel a bit exposed, having just been described to a “T”, but I’m comfortable with it by now, and, you’re right, it does make for an interesting life.
I was born an EO, on an island in the Caribbean, the only white baby in the hospital. But there are benefits: I am positive that I was definitely NOT switched at birth, and being an EO lends itself to being comfortable wherever and with whomever you find yourself.
Think of it as being just the opposite of ethnocentric, ahem.
I was at a conference in Anchorage the other day, listening to some authority on diabetes, talking something about statistical analysis. Something rose up in me and I commented in a room full of people, “You know, if we keep studying this without doing anything to actually help them, some day we may have no more diabetics left to study”.
I know you were there in spirit, and that’s what made me brave. Thanks for being you.
So, yes, being a Enigmatic Opportunist has its moments, but I wouldn’t trade it for all the tea in China. Chief Paul of Beaver says hi.
Donna, what is a Gladwellian Connector?
Nurse Tim, say hi to Chief Paul for me. I wrote about him briefly for a new book called Diabetes Heroes, about people reversing Type 2. I’ll send you and him copies when it comes out. I like your “Enigmatic Opportunist.”
Very good, looking forward to it, thank you. I will pass on your greetings to the Chief.
Comment on Outsiders article: Hmm, seems I’ve found a group I can fit in with at long last.
More seriously, I definitely identify with much of the “EO” profile. But I have also found in my life the benefits of identifying and joining a structured community that alligns with my interests and supports many of my core values. I’ve found that I can enrich my own life as well as make a sustained contribution as an “insider” because I have made a committment to the welfare of the group and the individuals in it. My group is a performing arts organization, grounded in another culture with a strong tradition of community and service, minus the oppressiveness and rigidity of organized religion. So I guess that makes me an “EI” – eclectic insider.
Fran, I agree with you that being an insider can be good, if you have the right group to be inside. You can only accomplish so much without really committing. We’re blessed to live in a time and place where so many options are available, and I’m glad you’ve found one that works for you.
I do think, though, that EO is an identity that can at least provide support and comfort, and that EOs have a valuable place, even if it is on the outside. Aisha and I are thinking of throwing a big picnic or party and inviting anyone who identifies. You will be invited when it happens.
Can I come too? I might feel at home there but probably not.
So insightful, David, thanks; that explains a lot. I’ve thought about the concept quite a bit (e.g., Alexis de Toqueville, Jacob Riis, Jacob Holdt), but never really applied it to myself.
Brook’s Minority:
Minorities will know more about majorities than majorities know about minorities and, sometimes, even more than majorities will know about themselves.